Gospel Standard Strict Baptists

The Gospel Standard Strict Baptists, sometimes called Gospel Standard Baptists, or Gadsbyites, are a group of Strict Baptists who originated in the 19th century from their association with the Gospel Standard Magazine. As of July 2023, there were seventy-nine chapels located in the United Kingdom, three in the United States, two in Canada, and two in Australia.

History

The Particular Baptists

The Particular Baptists emerged in 17th-century England as part of the larger Puritan movement, distinguishing themselves from General Baptists by their adherence to Calvinist doctrine, particularly the belief in particular redemption (that Christ died only for the elect). They formed as a distinct group in the 1630s and 1640s when congregations, influenced by Calvinism, began practicing believer’s baptism by immersion.

Particular Baptists were heavily influenced by Reformed theology and the separatist principles of the Puritans, emphasizing a gathered church of professing believers rather than a state church. They faced persecution under the English monarchy, especially before the English Civil War, but gained some freedom during the Commonwealth period. In 1644, they formalized their beliefs in what came to be known as the First London Baptist Confession of Faith, which laid out their distinct doctrines and defended them against charges of Anabaptism. They later adopted another confession of faith that was published in 1689, based on the Westminster Confession and Savoy Declaration. This confession came to be known as the Second London Baptist Confession.

Controversies

The Gospel Standard Baptists emerged from a series of controversies within the Particular Baptist tradition in 19th-century England. The roots of these controversies trace back to earlier debates among English Baptists over the extent of the Atonement and the participants of the Lord's Supper.

High Calvinism & Hyper-Calvinism

In the 18th century, many Particular Baptists moved toward a "High" Calvinism and, in some cases, Hyper-Calvinism. High Calvinism within this context stressed God's sovereign grace in salvation, emphasizing Supralapsarianism and particular redemption. This view often results in a cautious approach to evangelism, as High Calvinists may be reluctant to extend general gospel invitations, concerned that doing so might imply that anyone can choose to be saved. Hyper-Calvinism took this further by asserting that it was wrong to call all people to repentance and faith, as such a call would imply that non-elect individuals had a "duty" to believe in Christ. Hyper-Calvinists argued that gospel invitations should be extended only to those who showed signs of being among the elect. This stance arose partly as a reaction to the Arminian influence within broader Protestantism, which emphasized human free will in salvation.

The shift to Hyper-Calvinism led to a decline in evangelistic efforts among some Particular Baptists, creating divisions among them. This theological stance caused some churches to distance themselves from revivalism and missionary societies and contributed to a period of stagnation. By the 19th century, figures like Andrew Fuller advocated for a more moderate Calvinism, arguing that gospel preaching should include a universal call to faith.

Strict Communion

The controversy over Closed and Open Communion among Particular Baptists primarily centered on differing views about who could participate in the Lord's Supper. Proponents of Closed Communion argued that only baptized believers who were members of their own church or like-minded congregations should be allowed to partake. In contrast, adherents of Open Communion allowed any professing Christian, regardless of baptism status or church membership, to participate in the Lord's Supper.

The debate became particularly intense in the 19th century, as figures like William Gadsby and other Strict Baptists argued that Open Communion compromised Baptist principles and undermined doctrinal purity. Meanwhile, influential pastors like Charles Spurgeon practiced Open Communion, seeing it as an expression of Christian unity. This controversy contributed to splits within Particular Baptist circles, leading to the formation of groups like the Gospel Standard Baptists, who strongly upheld Closed Communion as part of their distinct identity.

The Gospel Standard

William Gadsby, a significant figure in this tradition, along with his contemporaries John Warburton and John Kershaw, became known for advocating a “High” Calvinist theology. They argued against what they saw as deviations from true Calvinism within evangelical circles, particularly criticizing the rising trend of evangelistic methods like altar calls and the use of emotional appeals. Gadsby especially viewed these as threats to the doctrine of God’s sovereignty in salvation, fearing that such methods leaned towards Arminianism, or even Pelagianism, by implying that human decision played a role in salvation. These doctrinal convictions led to the establishment of the Gospel Standard magazine in 1835 by his son, John Gadsby, which aimed to propagate these convictions.

Through the Gospel Standard, Gadsby and his associates articulated positions that were controversial even within the Strict Baptist community. They rejected "duty faith," the belief that all people are obligated to believe in Christ, insisting instead that faith is a gift given only to the elect. This stance became a divisive issue, as some Particular Baptists felt it bordered on Hyper-Calvinism and discouraged gospel preaching to non-believers. Nevertheless, Gadsby’s views gained traction among Strict Baptist congregations who were wary of evangelical revivalism and sought a clearer distinction from more mainstream Baptists.

This tension eventually led to a formal split, as churches aligned with Gadsby’s Gospel Standard positions formally separated themselves from other Strict Baptist congregations. In 1878, the Gospel Standard Articles of Faith were published, codifying their doctrinal distinctives, including views on the sovereignty of God, limited atonement, and the necessity of a clear profession of faith and sound doctrine for church membership. Additionally, the articles prescribed practices like “restricted communion,” where only those from churches adhering to Gospel Standard principles could participate in the Lord’s Supper.

The Gospel Standard Trust

The Gospel Standard Baptists continued to operate somewhat autonomously until 1967, when the Gospel Standard Trust was established to provide legal, financial, and logistical support for the churches and the publication. The Trust helped formalize and sustain the infrastructure necessary for these congregations and safeguarded their commitment to the original principles articulated by Gadsby and his peers. The Trust also oversees the continuing publication of the Gospel Standard magazine, which remains central to the identity and doctrinal unity of these churches.

Today, the Gospel Standard Trust ensures the preservation of the Gospel Standard heritage, managing assets for the churches, supporting ministers, and publishing doctrinal literature. The controversies and splits that led to the formation of Gospel Standard Baptists remain influential in their theology and church practices, with a deep-seated emphasis on maintaining doctrinal purity, restricting communion, and avoiding perceived worldliness. Although their numbers are relatively small, Gospel Standard Baptists have retained a distinct, committed identity within the broader landscape of Reformed Baptists.

Doctrine

Gospel Standard Baptists are generally aligned with the Second London Baptist Confession (1689) and the Gospel Standard Articles of Faith.

See also

• Gospel Standard
• Strict Baptists

Prominent People

• William Gadsby (1773–1844)
• John Warburton (1776–1857)
• Joseph Irons (1785–1852)
• John Kershaw (1792–1870)
• John Foreman (1792–1872)
• J.C. Philpot (1802–1869)
• James Popham (1847–1937)
• Frank Gosden (1890–1980)
• Benjamin Ramsbottom(1929–2023)

Further Reading

Primary Sources

• Gadsby, J. (1851). The Works of the Late William Gadsby, Vol. 1, Vol. 2. Accessed 11/02/2024.
• Gadsby. William (1838). A Selection of Hymns For Public Worship. Accessed 11/02/2024.

Secondary Sources

• Dix, Kenneth (2001). Strict and Particular: English Strict and Particular Baptists in the Nineteenth Century. ISBN: 978-0903166317
• Garrett, Jr., James Leo (2009). Baptist Theology: A Four-Century Study. Mercer University Press. pgs. 198–200. ISBN 978-0-88146-129-9
• Gosden, J.H. (1993). What Gospel Standard Baptists Believe. ISBN 978-0951079614.
• Ramsbottom, B.A. (1985) The History of The Gospel Standard Magazine 1835-2010. ISBN 978-0951079607

External Links

• Official Website
• True Gospel Resources